My experience was good all the way. He was attentive before and after surgery. I've seen him once since surgery (and once the PA) and have one more appt. with him. He told me what to expect and he was right -- that after surgery on my hip my knee would feel better and it is fine also. I can walk well (5 mos. out from surgery) with no pain, doing things I haven't been able to do in a long time (over 2 years). My advice -- don't wait -- don't suffer needlessly -- he is excellent.